Are they not, as poets are
always telling us, inaccurate witnesses?
always telling us, inaccurate witnesses?
Tennyson
, Sc.
5:--
and _the elements_
So mix'd in' him that Nature, etc. ]
[Footnote 5: An excellent commentary on this is Clough's
_Perche pensa, pensando vecchia_. ]
[Footnote 6: 'Cf'. Job xiv. 21:
"His sons come to honour, and he knowcth it not; and they are brought
low, but he perceiveth it not of them. "]
[Footnote 7: So Bishop Butler, 'Analogy', ch. i. :
"We cannot argue _from the reason of the thing_ that death is the
destruction of living agents because we know not at all what death is
in itself, but only some of its effects". ]
[Footnote 8: So Milton, enfolding this idea of death, 'Paradise
Lost', ii. , 672-3:--
What seemed his head
The _likeness_ of a kingly crown had on. ]
[Footnote 9: 'Cf'. Plato, 'Phaedo', x. :--
[Greek: ara echei alaetheian tina opsis te kai akoae tois anthr_opois.
Ae ta ge toiauta kai oi poiaetai haemin aei thrulousin oti out
akouomen akribes ouden oute or_omen]
"Have sight and hearing any truth in them?
Are they not, as poets are
always telling us, inaccurate witnesses? "
The proper commentary on the whole of this passage is Plato
'passim', but the 'Phaedo' particularly, 'cf. Republic',
vii. , viii. and xiv. -xv. ]
[Footnote 10: An allusion to the myth that when souls are sent to occupy
a body again they drink of Lethe that they may forget their previous
existence. See the famous passage towards the end of the tenth book of
Plato's 'Republic':
"All persons are compelled to drink a certain quantity of the water,
but those who are not preserved by prudence drink more than the
quantity, and each as he drinks forgets everything".
So Milton, 'Paradise Lost', ii. , 582-4. ]
[Footnote 11: The best commentary on this will be found in Herbert
Spencer's 'Psychology'. ]
[Footnote 12: Compare with this Tennyson's first sonnet ('Works', Globe
Edition, 25), and the lines in the 'Ancient Sage' in the 'Passion of the
Past' ('Id'. , 551). 'Cf'. too the lines in Wordsworth's ode on
'Intimations of Immortality':--
But there's a tree, of many one,
A single field which I have looked upon,
Both of them speak of something that is gone;
The pansy at my feet
Doth the same tale repeat.
For other remarkable illustrations of this see the present writer's
'Illustrations of Tennyson', p.
5:--
and _the elements_
So mix'd in' him that Nature, etc. ]
[Footnote 5: An excellent commentary on this is Clough's
_Perche pensa, pensando vecchia_. ]
[Footnote 6: 'Cf'. Job xiv. 21:
"His sons come to honour, and he knowcth it not; and they are brought
low, but he perceiveth it not of them. "]
[Footnote 7: So Bishop Butler, 'Analogy', ch. i. :
"We cannot argue _from the reason of the thing_ that death is the
destruction of living agents because we know not at all what death is
in itself, but only some of its effects". ]
[Footnote 8: So Milton, enfolding this idea of death, 'Paradise
Lost', ii. , 672-3:--
What seemed his head
The _likeness_ of a kingly crown had on. ]
[Footnote 9: 'Cf'. Plato, 'Phaedo', x. :--
[Greek: ara echei alaetheian tina opsis te kai akoae tois anthr_opois.
Ae ta ge toiauta kai oi poiaetai haemin aei thrulousin oti out
akouomen akribes ouden oute or_omen]
"Have sight and hearing any truth in them?
Are they not, as poets are
always telling us, inaccurate witnesses? "
The proper commentary on the whole of this passage is Plato
'passim', but the 'Phaedo' particularly, 'cf. Republic',
vii. , viii. and xiv. -xv. ]
[Footnote 10: An allusion to the myth that when souls are sent to occupy
a body again they drink of Lethe that they may forget their previous
existence. See the famous passage towards the end of the tenth book of
Plato's 'Republic':
"All persons are compelled to drink a certain quantity of the water,
but those who are not preserved by prudence drink more than the
quantity, and each as he drinks forgets everything".
So Milton, 'Paradise Lost', ii. , 582-4. ]
[Footnote 11: The best commentary on this will be found in Herbert
Spencer's 'Psychology'. ]
[Footnote 12: Compare with this Tennyson's first sonnet ('Works', Globe
Edition, 25), and the lines in the 'Ancient Sage' in the 'Passion of the
Past' ('Id'. , 551). 'Cf'. too the lines in Wordsworth's ode on
'Intimations of Immortality':--
But there's a tree, of many one,
A single field which I have looked upon,
Both of them speak of something that is gone;
The pansy at my feet
Doth the same tale repeat.
For other remarkable illustrations of this see the present writer's
'Illustrations of Tennyson', p.